Identification of Black Spot Pathogen in Cabbage，Analysis of Biological Characteristics，and Screening of Resistant Germplasm Resources

doi:10.16420/j.issn.0513-353x.2025-0509

Acta Horticulturae Sinica ›› 2026, Vol. 53 ›› Issue (5): 1502-1520.doi: 10.16420/j.issn.0513-353x.2025-0509

• Plant Protection • Previous Articles Next Articles

Identification of Black Spot Pathogen in Cabbage，Analysis of Biological Characteristics，and Screening of Resistant Germplasm Resources

WANG Caihong¹, ZHANG Yangyong², LI Sen¹, ZHANG Chaowen¹, KONG Xiaoping³, LÜ Honghao², WANG Yong², YANG Limei², JI Jialei²^,^*(), ZHUANG Mu²^,^*()

¹ College of Horticulture， Shanxi Agricultural University，Taigu， Shanxi 030801， China
² State Key Laboratory of Vegetable Biobreeding， Institute of Vegetables and Flowers，Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences， Beijing 100081， China
³ Xining Vegetable Technology Service Center， Xining 810016， China

Received:2025-09-28 Revised:2025-12-19 Online:2026-05-26 Published:2026-05-26
Contact: JI Jialei, ZHUANG Mu

Abstract

Abstract:

Black spot disease is one of the major constraints in cabbage production. Multiple black spot disease samples were collected from five major cabbage production regions Beijing，Chongqing，Hubei，Sichuan，and Inner Mongolia. After isolation and purification，30 strains of the pathogen were obtained. Morphological characteristics of the colonies，conidia，and conidial chains of the pathogen were observed and described. Pathogenicity tests conducted using mycelial plug inoculation identified the BJA1 strain from Beijing as the most virulent. Molecular identification through cloning and phylogenetic analysis of the ITS，TEF1，and GAPDH genes confirmed that BJA1 is a typical strain of Alternaria brassicicola. Using this strain，an efficient and stable in vitro inoculation system for evaluating resistance to cabbage black spot disease was established. The optimal spore concentration for inoculation was determined to be 1 × 10⁵ spores · mL^-1，and the ideal plant growth stage for inoculation was the four-leaf stage. This system was applied to evaluate the resistance of 100 cabbage germplasms to black spot disease，leading to the identification of 24 moderately resistant accessions and one resistant accession with a disease index of 25.93.

Key words: cabbage, black spot disease, Alternaria brassicicola, resistance evaluation, resistant source screening

WANG Caihong, ZHANG Yangyong, LI Sen, ZHANG Chaowen, KONG Xiaoping, LÜ Honghao, WANG Yong, YANG Limei, JI Jialei, ZHUANG Mu. Identification of Black Spot Pathogen in Cabbage，Analysis of Biological Characteristics，and Screening of Resistant Germplasm Resources[J]. Acta Horticulturae Sinica, 2026, 53(5): 1502-1520.

Figures/Tables 16

References 35

[1]	Ben-Noon E, Shtienberg D, Shlevin E, Vintal H, Dinoor A. 2001. Optimization of chemical suppression of Alternaria dauci,the causal agent of Alternaria leaf blight in carrots. Plant Disease, 85 (11):1149-1156. doi: 10.1094/PDIS.2001.85.11.1149 pmid: 30823158
[2]	Berbee M L, Pirseyedi M, Hubbard S. 1999. Cochliobolus phylogenetics and the origin of known,highly virulent pathogens,inferred from ITS and glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase gene sequences. Mycologia, 91 (6):964-977. doi: 10.1080/00275514.1999.12061106 URL
[3]	Cai Yongzhan, Bai Tao, Liu Dongmei, Qiu Chunli, Fu Zongwei, Zhu Yingxun, Hua Xiaobing, Zhao Chongjun, Zhang Qi. 2022. Isolation and screening of endophytic bacteria for effective biocontrol of tobacco brown spot and optimization of fermentation and culture conditions. Jiangsu Agricultural Sciences, 50 (13):129-135. (in Chinese)
	蔡永占, 白涛, 刘冬梅, 邱春丽, 符宗伟, 朱颖勋, 华小兵, 赵崇钧, 张琪. 2022. 烟草赤星病高效生防内生细菌的分离筛选及发酵培养条件优化. 江苏农业科学, 50 (13):129-135.
[4]	Cenis J L. 1992. Rapid extraction of fungal DNA for PCR amplification. Nucleic Acids Research, 20 (9):2380. doi: 10.1093/nar/20.9.2380 pmid: 1594460
[5]	Cheng H, Zhao L, Wei X, Liu X, Gao G Y, Deng J X, Li M J. 2022. Alternaria species causing leaf spot on hemp(Cannabis sativa)in Northern China. European Journal of Plant Pathology,162:957-970.
[6]	Conn K L, Tewari J P, Dahiya J S. 1998. Resistance to Alternaria brassicae and phytoalexin-elicitation in rapeseed and other crucif. Plant Science, 56 (1):21-25. doi: 10.1016/0168-9452(88)90180-X URL
[7]	Fang Zhiyuan. 2017. Vegetable breeding in China. Beijing:China Agriculture Press:268-269. (in Chinese)
	方智远. 2017. 中国蔬菜育种学. 北京:中国农业出版社:268-269.
[8]	Fang Zhongda. 1998. Plant disease research methods. Beijing: China Agriculture Press:122. (in Chinese)
	方中达. 1998. 植病研究方法. 北京: 中国农业出版社:122.
[9]	Feng Zhonghong, Sun Guangyu. 2020. Advances in the classification of Alternaria and related genera. Journal of Fungal Research, 18 (4):294-303. (in Chinese)
	冯中红, 孙广宇. 2020. 链格孢属及相关属分类研究新进展. 菌物研究, 18 (4):294-303.
[10]	Guo Runting. 2018. The identification of Alternaria on vegetable and research of new diseases in China[M. D. Dissertation]. Beijing: Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences. (in Chinese)
	郭润婷. 2018. 主要蔬菜链格孢病原菌的鉴定与新病害研究[硕士论文]. 北京: 中国农业科学院.
[11]	Hai Ting, Yi Jun, Zeng Shuocheng, Fu Huijuan, Ye Jianrong, Li Xingyue. 2025. Harm and control measures of black spot disease in cruciferous vegetables. Modern Agricultural Science and Technology,(3):82-85. (in Chinese)
	海婷, 易军, 曾铄程, 符慧娟, 叶建蓉, 李星月. 2025. 十字花科蔬菜黑斑病的危害及防治措施. 现代农业科技,(3):82-85.
[12]	Hansen L N, Earle E D. 1997. Somatic hybrids between Brassica oleracea L. and Sinapis alba L. with resistance to Alternaria brassicae(Berk.)Sacc. Theoretical and Applied Genetics, 94 (8):1078-1085. doi: 10.1007/s001220050518 URL
[13]	He Jie, Liang Shuang, Zhang Guojun, Zhao Zhi, Li Zhong. 2021. Pathogen identification and screening of fungicides against Pseudostellaria heterophylla(Miq.) Pax leaf spot. Journal of Southern Agriculture, 52 (8):2124-2132. (in Chinese)
	何洁, 梁霜, 张国俊, 赵致, 李忠. 2021 太子参叶斑病病原鉴定及室内药剂筛选. 南方农业学报, 52 (8):2124-2132.
[14]	Huang Shiwen, Yu Liuqing, Alan K W. 2001. Factors affecting growth and sporulation of Alternaria alternata Chinese Journal of Biological Control,(1):16-19. (in Chinese)
	黄世文, 余柳青, Alan K W. 2001. 影响链格孢菌生长及产孢的因子. 中国生物防治,(1):16-19.
[15]	Kumari P, Bisht D S, Bhat S R. 2018. Stable fertile somatic hybrids between Sinapis alba and Brassica juncea show resistance to Alternaria brassicae and heat stress. Plant Cell, Tissue and Organ Culture, 133 (1):77-86. doi: 10.1007/s11240-017-1362-9 URL
[16]	Li Jiehua, Wang Qianqian, He Yuhua, Zhao Shuang, Liu Ye, Zhang Fei, Chen Fadi, Fang Weimin. 2025. Optimization of sporulation conditions and inoculation system of chrysanthemum black spot pathogen. Journal of Nuclear Agricultural Sciences, 39 (4):728-736. (in Chinese) doi: 10.11869/j.issn.1000-8551.2025.04.0728
	黎洁华, 王倩倩, 何玉华, 赵爽, 刘晔, 张飞, 陈发棣, 房伟民. 2025. 菊花黑斑病菌产孢条件及接种体系优化. 核农学报, 39 (4):728-736. doi: 10.11869/j.issn.1000-8551.2025.04.0728
[17]	Liu X, Zhao D, Ou C, Hao W, Zhang Y, He Y, Zhao Z, Zhuang F. 2023. Draft genome sequence of carrot alternaria leaf blight pathogen Alternaria dauci. Plant Disease, 107 (7):2197-2200.
[18]	Liu Zhigang, Yu Fangwei, Zhang Wei, Yu Li, Li Jianbin, Wang Shenyun, Song Jianghua. 2023. Identification and fungicide sensitivity of the pathogen causing black spot on Brassica oleracea var. capitata L. Jiangsu Journal of Agricultural Sciences, 39 (4):947-955. (in Chinese)
	刘志刚, 余方伟, 张伟, 于利, 李建斌, 王神云, 宋江华. 2023. 甘蓝黑斑病病原菌鉴定及其对杀菌剂的敏感性. 江苏农业学报, 39 (4):947-955.
[19]	Lou Xiyan, Guo Yangyang, Pei Dongli. 2021. Identification and biological characteristics of pathogen of rose black spot in Shangqiu, Henan Province. Jiangsu Agricultural Sciences, 49 (19):138-143. (in Chinese)
	娄喜艳, 郭洋洋, 裴冬丽. 2021 河南商丘月季黑斑病病原菌鉴定及生物学特性. 江苏农业科学, 49 (19):138-143.
[20]	Saharan G S, Menhta N, Meena P D. 2016. Alternaria diseases of crucifers:biology, ecology and disease management. Singapore:Springer.
[21]	Shen Yusen, Wang Jiansheng, Sheng Xiaoguang, Zhao Zhenqing, Yu Huifang, Gu Honghui. 2021. Research progress on black spot in cruciferous plants. Journal of Nuclear Agricultural Sciences, 35 (3):623-634. (in Chinese) doi: 10.11869/j.issn.100-8551.2021.03.0623
	沈钰森, 王建升, 盛小光, 赵振卿, 虞慧芳, 顾宏辉. 2021. 十字花科植物黑斑病的研究进展. 核农学报, 35 (3):623-634. doi: 10.11869/j.issn.100-8551.2021.03.0623
[22]	Shi Zhaorong, Zhang Guangrong, Sun Shujun, Jin Mengjun, Cui Lingxiao, Liu Yanchao, Wei Lijuan, Mei Dahai, Yang Chengde. 2022. Isolation and identification of melon black spot in Gansu Province. Acta Horticulturae Sinica, 49 (2):427-436. (in Chinese) doi: 10.16420/j.issn.0513-353x.2020-0929
	施兆荣, 张广荣, 孙述俊, 金梦军, 崔凌霄, 刘彦超, 魏立娟, 梅大海, 杨成德. 2022. 甘肃省甜瓜黑斑病菌(Alternaria tenuissima)的分离鉴定. 园艺学报, 49 (2):427-436. doi: 10.16420/j.issn.0513-353x.2020-0929
[23]	Song Jian. 2015. Fang Zhongda and the study of plant disease research[M. D. Dissertation]. Nanjing: Nanjing Agricultural University. (in Chinese)
	宋健. 2015. 方中达与植物病害研究[硕士论文]. 南京: 南京农业大学.
[24]	Wang B, Zhang Y Y, Liu J P, Sheng O, Liu F, Qiu D L, Lü P E, Deng G M, Cheng C Z. 2021. A new leaf blight disease caused by Alternaria jacinthicola on banana in China. Horticulturae, 8 (1):12. doi: 10.3390/horticulturae8010012 URL
[25]	Wang Chao, Zhang Xiaoxuan, Wang Ningning. 2012. Identification of blackspot disease pathogen in cabbage//Proceedings of the 10th Academic Symposium of the Brassica Vegetables Branch,Chinese Society for Horticultural Science:166-170. (in Chinese)
	王超, 张晓烜, 王宁宁, 2012. 甘蓝黑斑病病原菌鉴定//中国园艺学会十字花科蔬菜分会第十届学术研讨会论文集:166-170.
[26]	Wang Wenqing. 2021. Differentiation of virulence andidentification of mycoviruses in Alternaria spp causing pear black spot[M. D. Dissertation]. Wuhan: Huazhong Agricultural University. (in Chinese)
	王文青. 2021. 梨黑斑病病原菌致病力分化分析与链格孢病毒的鉴定[硕士论文]. 武汉: 华中农业大学.
[27]	Wang Zhengxian. 2021. Pathogen identification of guava fruit diseases in yulin city of Guangxi and biological characteristics research of the pathogen of black spot[M. D. Dissertation]. Nanning: Guangxi University. (in Chinese)
	王正贤. 2021. 广西玉林市番石榴果实病害的病原菌鉴定及黑斑病菌的生物学特性研究[硕士论文]. 南宁: 广西大学.
[28]	White T J, Bruns T, Lee S B, Taylor J W. 1990. Amplification and direct sequencing of fungal ribosomal RNA genes for phylogenetics. PCR Protocols:A Guide to Methods and Applications, 18 (1):315-322.
[29]	Woudenberg J H, Seidl M F, Geoenewald J Z, de Vries M, Stielow J B, Thomma B P, Crous P W. 2015. Alternaria section Alternaria:species,formae speciales or pathotype? Studies in Mycology, 82:1-21. doi: 10.1016/j.simyco.2015.07.001 pmid: 26951037
[30]	Xin Zhulin, Cui Yanjuan, Yang Xiaowei, Kong Lingbo, Lin Qiao. 2022. Current situation of global vegetable industry and research progress of vegetable breeding development path in China. Molecular Plant Breeding, 20 (9):3122-3132. (in Chinese)
	辛竹琳, 崔彦娟, 杨小薇, 孔令博, 林巧. 2022. 全球蔬菜产业现状及中国蔬菜育种发展路径研究进展. 分子植物育种, 20 (9):3122-3132.
[31]	Yang Limei, Fang Zhiyuan. 2022. Researches on cabbage genetics and breeding in China for 60 years. Acta Horticulturae Sinica, 49 (10):2075-2098. (in Chinese) doi: 10.16420/j.issn.0513-353x.2022-0711
	杨丽梅, 方智远. 2022. 中国甘蓝遗传育种研究60年. 园艺学报, 49 (10):2075-2098. doi: 10.16420/j.issn.0513-353x.2022-0711
[32]	Yang Yingxia, Chen Rui, Yao Xingwei. 2023. Molecular breeding of brassica oleracea vegetables:a review. Journal of Agriculture, 13 (3):44-51. (in Chinese)
	杨迎霞, 陈锐, 姚星伟. 2023. 甘蓝类蔬菜分子育种研究进展. 农学学报, 13 (3):44-51. doi: 10.11923/j.issn.2095-4050.cjas2021-0220
[33]	Zhang Tianyu. 2003. Flora Fungorum Sinicorum——Alternaria. Beijing: Science Press. (in Chinese)
	张天宇. 2003. 中国真菌志——链格孢属. 北京: 科学出版社.
[34]	Zhao Donghang. 2024. Screening of resistant germplasm resources in carrot(Daucus carota L.)Alternaria leaf blight and mapping of resistance[M. D. Dissertation]. Beijing: Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences. (in Chinese)
	赵东航. 2024. 胡萝卜黑斑病抗性种质资源筛选和抗病基因定位[硕士论文]. 北京: 中国农业科学院.
[35]	Zhu Jie, Cheng Liang, Zhang Gang, Chen Hongyu, Fu Liying, Yao Qiang, Guo Qingyun. 2021. Screening and identification of Bacillus atrophaeus QH-588 for biological control of cherry leaf spot. Journal of Southern Agriculture, 52 (11):3022-3033. (in Chinese)
	朱杰, 程亮, 张纲, 陈红雨, 付丽颖, 姚强, 郭青云. 2021 樱桃叶斑病生防菌株萎缩芽孢杆菌菌株QH-588的筛选鉴定. 南方农业学报, 52 (11):3022-3033.

引物 Primer	目标片段 Target region	序列 Primers sequence	参考文献 Reference
ITS	ITS1	5′-TCCTCCGCTTATTGATATGC-3′	White et al.,1990
ITS	ITS4	5′-CCGTAGGTGAACCTGCGG-3′	White et al.,1990
TEF1	TEF1	5′-CATCGAGAAGTTCGAGAAGG-3′	赵东航,2024
TEF1	TEF2	5′-TACTTGAAGGAACCCTTACC-3′	赵东航,2024
GAPDH	gpd1	5′-CAACGGCTTCGGTCGCATTG-3′	Berbee et al.,1999
GAPDH	gpd2	5′-GCCAAGCAGTTGGTTGTGC-3′	Berbee et al.,1999

引物 Primer	目标片段 Target region	序列 Primers sequence	参考文献 Reference
ITS	ITS1	5′-TCCTCCGCTTATTGATATGC-3′	White et al.,1990
ITS	ITS4	5′-CCGTAGGTGAACCTGCGG-3′	White et al.,1990
TEF1	TEF1	5′-CATCGAGAAGTTCGAGAAGG-3′	赵东航,2024
TEF1	TEF2	5′-TACTTGAAGGAACCCTTACC-3′	赵东航,2024
GAPDH	gpd1	5′-CAACGGCTTCGGTCGCATTG-3′	Berbee et al.,1999
GAPDH	gpd2	5′-GCCAAGCAGTTGGTTGTGC-3′	Berbee et al.,1999

基因 Gene	预变性 Initial denaturation	变性（循环次数35） Denaturation（Number of cycles 35）	退火 Annealing	延伸 Extension	补充延伸 Final extension
ITS	95 ℃，30 s	95 ℃，15 s	60 ℃，15 s	72 ℃，10 s	72 ℃，5 min
TEF1	95 ℃，30 s	95 ℃，15 s	60 ℃，15 s	72 ℃，10 s	72 ℃，5 min
GAPDH	94 ℃，5 min	94 ℃，15 s	58 ℃，15 s	72 ℃，20 s	72 ℃，5 min

基因 Gene	预变性 Initial denaturation	变性（循环次数35） Denaturation（Number of cycles 35）	退火 Annealing	延伸 Extension	补充延伸 Final extension
ITS	95 ℃，30 s	95 ℃，15 s	60 ℃，15 s	72 ℃，10 s	72 ℃，5 min
TEF1	95 ℃，30 s	95 ℃，15 s	60 ℃，15 s	72 ℃，10 s	72 ℃，5 min
GAPDH	94 ℃，5 min	94 ℃，15 s	58 ℃，15 s	72 ℃，20 s	72 ℃，5 min

抗性级别 Resistance level	病情指数 Disease index（DI）	抗性级别 Resistance level	病情指数 Disease index（DI）
高抗 Highly resistant（HR）	0.10 ~ 11.11	感病 Susceptible（S）	55.55 ~ 77.77
抗病 Resistant（R）	11.11 ~ 33.33	高感 Highly susceptible（HS）	77.77 ~ 100
中抗 Moderately resistant（MR）	33.33 ~ 55.55

Identification of Black Spot Pathogen in Cabbage，Analysis of Biological Characteristics，and Screening of Resistant Germplasm Resources

RichHTML

PDF

Knowledge

Abstract

Cite this article

share this article

Figures/Tables 16

References 35

Related Articles 15

Recommended Articles

Metrics

Comments

菌株 Strain	菌落形态 Colony morphology	分生孢子特征 Conidium characterization
		形态 Morphological	孢子直径/μm Diameter of a spore	隔膜数 Number of diaphragms
		形态 Morphological	孢子直径/μm Diameter of a spore	横隔膜 Diaphragm	纵隔膜 Longitudinal diaphragm
SCA1	同心轮纹，中心呈黑褐色，外围呈均匀灰褐色，气生菌丝少，且分生孢子茂密Concentric rings with dark brown centers and uniformly gray-brown margins，exhibiting sparse aerial mycelium but abundant conidial production	倒棒状，无喙或不明显 Obclavate，beakless or with indistinct beak	（4.26 ~ 10.90）× （2.26 ~ 3.60）	1 ~ 5	0 ~ 1
SCA2	同心轮纹，菌落呈黑褐色，气生菌丝少，且分生孢子茂密Concentric rings with dark brown colonies，sparse aerial mycelium，and dense conidiation	倒棒状，无喙或不明显 Obclavate，beakless or with indistinct beak	（3.01 ~ 4.92）× （2.70 ~ 3.72）	1 ~ 4	0 ~ 5
SCB1	同心轮纹，中心呈黑褐色，外围呈均匀黄褐色，气生菌丝发达，且分生孢子茂密Concentric rings with dark brown centers，uniformly tan margins，abundant aerial mycelium，and dense conidiation	倒棒状或卵形，无喙或不明显Obclavate or ovoid，beakless or with indistinct beak	（3.33 ~ 12.11）× （2.47 ~ 2.91）	1 ~ 3	0 ~ 1
SCB2	同心轮纹，中心呈黑褐色，外围呈均匀灰褐色，气生菌丝少，且分生孢子茂密Concentric rings with dark brown centers，uniformly gray-brown margins，sparse aerial mycelium，and dense conidiation	倒棒状，无喙或不明显 Obclavate，beakless or with indistinct beak	（4.08 ~ 8.39）× （2.71 ~ 2.87）	1 ~ 3	0
SCC1	同心轮纹，中心呈黑褐色，外围呈均匀灰褐色，气生菌丝少，且分生孢子茂密Concentric rings with dark brown centers，uniformly gray-brown edges，sparse aerial hyphae，and dense conidia	倒棒状或卵形，无喙或不明显Obclavate or ovoid，beakless or with indistinct beak	（3.50 ~ 8.59）× （1.88 ~ 3.07）	1 ~ 3	0 ~ 1
SCC2	同心轮纹，中心呈黑褐色，外围呈均匀黄褐色，气生菌丝少，且分生孢子茂密Concentric rings with dark brown centers，uniformly tan margins，sparse aerial mycelium，and dense conidiation	倒棒状，无喙或不明显 Obclavate，beakless or with indistinct beak	（3.43 ~ 8.14）× （2.14 ~ 3.36）	1 ~ 4	0 ~ 4
NMA1	菌落呈黄白色，气生菌丝发达，且分生孢子茂密 Colonies appear yellowish-white with luxuriant aerial mycelium and dense conidiation	卵形或近球形，无喙或不明显Ovoid or subglobose，beakless or with indistinct beak	（2.75 ~ 4.10）× （2.27 ~ 3.50）	1 ~ 2	0 ~ 2
NMA2	菌落呈黄褐色和不均匀白色，气生菌丝发达，且分生孢子茂密Colonies exhibit tan and uneven white coloration with luxuriant aerial mycelium and dense conidiation	卵形或近球形，无喙或不明显Ovoid or subglobose，beakless or with indistinct beak	（2.60 ~ 4.51）× （1.84 ~ 2.80）	1 ~ 2	0 ~ 2
NMB1	菌落呈白色和不均匀黄褐色，气生菌丝发达，且分生孢子茂密Colonies appear white with uneven tan pigmentation，exhibiting luxuriant aerial mycelium and dense conidiation	卵形或近球形，无喙或不明显Ovoid or subglobose，beakless or with indistinct beak	（2.32 ~ 3.54）× （1.57 ~ 3.50）	1 ~ 2	0 ~ 2
NMB2	同心轮纹，菌落呈白色和黄褐色，气生菌丝发达，且分生孢子茂密 Concentric rings with white and tan colonies，luxuriant aerial mycelium，and dense conidiation	卵形或近球形，无喙或不明显Ovoid or subglobose，beakless or with indistinct beak	（2.68 ~ 3.32）× （1.79 ~ 2.55）	1 ~ 2	0 ~ 2
NMC1	菌落呈白色，气生菌丝发达，且分生孢子茂密White colonies with luxuriant aerial mycelium and dense conidiation	卵形或近球形，无喙或不明显Ovoid or subglobose，beakless or with indistinct beak	（2.37 ~ 4.75）× （1.61 ~ 2.73）	1 ~ 3	0 ~ 2
NMC2	菌落呈白色，气生菌丝发达，且分生孢子茂密White colonies with luxuriant aerial mycelium and dense conidiation	倒棒状，无喙或不明显 Obclavate，beakless or with indistinct beak	（3.14 ~ 7.67）× （2.08 ~ 2.54）	1 ~ 3	0 ~ 1
BJA1	同心轮纹，中心呈黑褐色，外围呈均匀灰褐色，气生菌丝少，且分生孢子茂密Concentric rings with dark brown centers，uniformly gray-brown margins，sparse aerial mycelium，and dense conidiation	倒棒状，无喙或不明显 Obclavate，beakless or with indistinct beak	（2.16 ~ 8.39）× （1.67 ~ 2.63）	1 ~ 3	0 ~ 1
BJA2	同心轮纹，中心呈黄褐色，外围不均匀黄褐色和白色，气生菌丝发达，且分生孢子茂密Concentric rings with tan centers，uneven tan and white margins，luxuriant aerial mycelium，and dense conidiation	倒棒状，无喙或不明显 Obclavate，beakless or with indistinct beak	（2.62 ~ 9.39）× （2.94 ~ 1.71）	1 ~ 3	0
BJB1	同心轮纹，中心呈黑褐色，外围呈均匀灰褐色，伴有不均匀白色菌落，气生菌丝发达，且分生孢子茂密Concentric rings with dark brown centers，uniformly gray-brown margins interspersed with irregular white colonies，exhibiting luxuriant aerial mycelium and dense conidiation	倒棒状，无喙或不明显 Obclavate，beakless or with indistinct beak	（2.40 ~ 7.00）× （1.49 ~ 3.29）	1 ~ 4	0~1
BJB1	同心轮纹，中心呈黄褐色，外围呈不均匀黑褐色，气生菌丝少，且分生孢子茂密Concentric rings with tan centers，unevenly dark brown margins，sparse aerial mycelium，and dense conidiation	倒棒状或卵形，无喙或短至不明显Obclavate or ovoid，beakless or with indistinct beak	（2.77 ~ 12.17）× （2.05 ~ 4.39）	1 ~ 3	0 ~ 1
BJC1	同心轮纹，中心呈黑褐色，外围呈均匀灰褐色，气生菌丝少，且分生孢子茂密Concentric rings with dark brown centers，uniformly gray-brown margins，sparse aerial mycelium，and dense conidiation	倒棒状或卵形，无喙或不明显Obclavate or ovoid，beakless or with indistinct beak	（3.13 ~ 14.13）× （1.67 ~ 4.64）	1 ~ 3	0 ~ 1
BJC2	同心轮纹，中心呈黑褐色，外围呈均匀灰褐色，气生菌丝少，且分生孢子茂密Concentric rings with dark brown centers，uniformly gray-brown margins，sparse aerial mycelium，and dense conidiation	倒棒状或卵形，无喙或不明显Obclavate or ovoid，beakless or with indistinct beak	（1.62 ~ 8.00）× （1.96 ~ 2.88）	1 ~ 3	0 ~ 1
HBA1	同心轮纹，中心呈黑褐色，外围呈均匀黄褐色，伴有不均匀白色菌落，气生菌丝发达，且分生孢子茂密 Concentric rings with dark brown centers，uniformly tan margins interspersed with irregular white colonies，exhibiting luxuriant aerial mycelium and dense conidiation	倒棒状或卵形，无喙或不明显Obclavate or ovoid，beakless or with indistinct beak	（3.07 ~ 5.88）× （1.67 ~ 2.28）	1 ~ 8	0 ~ 4
HBA2	同心轮纹，中心呈黑褐色，外围呈均匀黄褐色，伴有不均匀白色菌落，气生菌丝发达，且分生孢子茂密 Concentric rings with dark brown centers，uniformly tan margins featuring patchy white colonies，showing vigorous aerial mycelium and dense conidiation	倒棒状或卵形，无喙或不明显Obclavate or ovoid，beakless or with indistinct beak	（3.15 ~ 7.40）× （1.79 ~ 3.58）	1 ~ 8	0 ~ 4
HBB1	同心轮纹，中心呈灰白色，外围呈不均匀灰褐色，气生菌丝发达，且分生孢子茂密Concentric rings with gray-white centers，unevenly gray-brown margins，luxuriant aerial mycelium，and dense conidiation	倒棒状，无喙或不明显 Obclavate，beakless or with indistinct beak	（2.17 ~ 7.81）× （1.70 ~ 3.85）	1 ~ 8	0 ~ 4
HBB2	菌落呈黄褐色，伴有不均匀白色菌落，气生菌丝发达，且分生孢子茂密Tan colonies with irregular white sectors，exhibiting luxuriant aerial mycelium and dense conidiation	倒棒状或卵形，无喙或不明显Obclavate or ovoid，beakless or with indistinct beak	（3.31 ~ 6.11）× （1.09 ~ 2.16）	1 ~ 3	0 ~ 2
HBC1	菌落呈黄褐色，伴有不均匀白色菌落，气生菌丝发达，且分生孢子茂密Tan colonies with mottled white sectors，showing luxuriant aerial mycelium and dense conidiation	倒棒状或卵形，无喙或不明显Obclavate or ovoid，beakless or with indistinct beak	（2.47 ~ 7.17）× （1.71 ~ 3.28）	1 ~ 3	0 ~ 2
HBC2	菌落呈灰绿色，气生菌丝发达，且分生孢子茂密Gray- reen colonies with luxuriant aerial mycelium and dense conidiation	卵形或卵形，无喙或不明显 Ovoid or oval，beakless or with indistinct beak	（2.22 ~ 6.03）× （1.53 ~ 2.72）	1 ~ 3	0 ~ 5
CQA1	菌落呈灰色，气生菌丝发达，且分生孢子茂密 Gray colonies with luxuriant aerial mycelium and dense conidiation	倒棒状或卵形，无喙或不明显Obclavate or ovoid，beakless or with indistinct beak	（2.37 ~ 6.67）× （1.67 ~ 2.55）	1 ~ 3	0 ~ 2
CQA2	菌落多呈黄色，伴有不均匀白色菌落，气生菌丝发达，且分生孢子茂密Predominantly yellow colonies with irregular white sectors，exhibiting luxuriant aerial mycelium and dense conidiation	倒棒状，无喙或不明显 Obclavate，beakless or with indistinct beak	（3.77 ~ 4.73）× （1.89 ~ 2.78）	1 ~ 3	0 ~ 3
CQB1	菌落多呈黄色，伴有不均匀白色菌落，气生菌丝发达，且分生孢子茂密Colonies predominantly yellow with irregular white sectors，exhibiting luxuriant aerial mycelium and dense conidiation	倒棒状或卵形，无喙或不明显Obclavate or ovoid，beakless or with indistinct beak	（2.56 ~ 4.48）× （1.69 ~ 2.44）	1 ~ 3	0 ~ 3
CQB2	菌落呈均匀灰褐色，气生菌丝发达，且分生孢子茂密 Uniformly gray-brown colonies with luxuriant aerial mycelium and dense conidiation	卵形或近球形，无喙或不明显Ovoid or subglobose，beakless or with indistinct beak	（2.51 ~ 3.77）× （1.88 ~ 3.33）	1 ~ 3	0 ~ 3
CQC1	中心呈黄褐色，外围呈均匀灰白色，气生菌丝发达，且分生孢子茂密Tan centers with uniformly gray-white margins，exhibiting luxuriant aerial mycelium and dense conidiation	倒棒状，无喙或不明显 Obclavate，beakless or with indistinct beak	（2.41 ~ 7.43）× （1.84 ~ 3.02）	1 ~ 3	0 ~ 2
CQC2	中心呈黄褐色，外围呈均匀灰白色，气生菌丝发达，且分生孢子茂密Tan centers with uniformly gray-white margins，exhibiting luxuriant aerial mycelium and dense conidiation	倒棒状、卵形或近球形，无喙或不明显Obclavate，ovoid or subglobose，lacking a beak or with indistinct beak	（2.71 ~ 7.74）× （1.33 ~ 3.07）	1 ~ 3	0 ~ 2

菌株 Strains	主要产孢表型类型 Main spore-producing phenotypes
SCA1	次生分生孢子梗或孢子侧向分支，形成短孢子链 Secondary conidiophores or spores develop lateral branches，forming short spore chains
SCA2	高大乔木状的产孢表型 Tall arborescent sporulation phenotype
SCB1	矮树状分支的分生孢子短链 Short-branched dwarf-tree-like conidial chains
SCB2	分生孢子单生，分生孢子梗分支 Conidia single，conidiophores branched
SCC1	矮树状分支的分生孢子短链 Short-branched dwarf-tree-like conidial chains
SCC2	次生分生孢子梗或孢子侧向分支，形成短孢子链Secondary conidiophores or spores develop lateral branches，forming short spore chains
NMA1	分生孢子单生，分生孢子梗不分支 Conidia single，conidiophores unbranched
NMA2	分生孢子单生，分生孢子梗不分支 Conidia single，conidiophores unbranched
NMB1	分生孢子单生，分生孢子梗不分支 Conidia single，conidiophores unbranched
NMB2	分生孢子单生，分生孢子梗不分支 Conidia single，conidiophores unbranched
NMC1	分生孢子单生，分生孢子梗不分支 Conidia single，conidiophores unbranched
NMC2	次生分生孢子梗或孢子侧向分支，形成短孢子链 Secondary conidiophores or spores develop lateral branches，forming short spore chains
BJA1	矮树状分支的分生孢子短链 Short-branched dwarf-tree-like conidial chains
BJA2	矮树状分支的分生孢子短链 Short-branched dwarf-tree-like conidial chains
BJB1	矮树状分支的分生孢子短链 Short-branched dwarf-tree-like conidial chains
BJB1	分生孢子单生，分生孢子梗分支 Conidia single，conidiophores branched
BJC1	短或长，不分支的分生孢子链 Short or long，unbranched conidial chains
BJC2	次生分生孢子梗或孢子侧向分支，形成短孢子链Secondary conidiophores or spores develop lateral branches，forming short spore chains
HBA1	短或长，不分支的分生孢子链 Short or long，unbranched conidial chains
HBA2	短或长，不分支的分生孢子链 Short or long，unbranched conidial chains
HBB1	不分支或稀少短分支的长分生孢子链 Long conidial chains，unbranched or with sparse short branches
HBB2	短或长，不分支的分生孢子链 Short or long，unbranched conidial chains
HBC1	矮树状分支的分生孢子短链 Short-branched dwarf-tree-like conidial chains
HBC2	矮树状分支的分生孢子短链 Short-branched dwarf-tree-like conidial chains
CQA1	分生孢子单生，分生孢子梗分支 Conidia single，conidiophores branched
CQA2	矮树状分支的分生孢子短链 Short-branched dwarf-tree-like conidial chains
CQB1	次生分生孢子梗或孢子侧向分支，形成短孢子链Secondary conidiophores or spores develop lateral branches，forming short spore chains
CQB2	不分支或稀少短分支的长分生孢子链 Long conidial chains，unbranched or with sparse short branches
CQC1	分生孢子单生，分生孢子梗分支 Conidia single，conidiophores branched
CQC2	短或长，不分支的分生孢子链 Short or long，unbranched conidial chains

菌株 Strain	占比/% Ratio	菌株 Strain	占比/% Ratio	菌株 Strain	占比/% Ratio
SCA1	20.1	NMC2	18.4	CQA1	16.8
NMA1	17.7	BJA1	32.6	CQA2	5.1
NMA2	9.5	BJC1	23.4	CQB1	4.2
NMB2	9.8	BJC2	24.9	CQB2	6.7
NMC1	10.6	HBA1	19.4

编号 Number	材料 Material	人工离体接种鉴定 In vitro artificial inoculation evaluation		编号 Number	材料 Material	人工离体接种鉴定 In vitro artificial inoculation evaluation
编号 Number	材料 Material	病情指数 Disease index	抗病等级 Disease resistance rating	编号 Number	材料 Material	病情指数 Disease index	抗病等级 Disease resistance rating
AR1	秋德 Qiude	62.96	S	AR51	亚飞322 Yafei 322	66.67	S
AR2	明德 Mingde	85.19	HS	AR52	亚飞329 Yafei 329	74.07	S
AR3	湖月 Huyue	85.19	HS	AR53	嘉宝 Jiabao	85.19	HS
AR4	梦午台310 Mengwutai 310	81.48	HS	AR54	BI16	92.59	HS
AR5	YR梦午台307 YR Mengwutai 307	92.59	HS	AR55	99-109	66.67	S
AR6	奥289 Ao 289	51.85	MR	AR56	99-198	74.07	S
AR7	奥213 Ao 213	81.48	HS	AR57	绿缘355 Lüyuan 355	88.89	HS
AR8	奥214 Ao 214	85.19	HS	AR58	绿缘356 Lüyuan 356	96.30	HS
AR9	奥215 Ao 215	66.67	S	AR59	湖北1186-1 Hubei 1186-1	92.59	HS
AR10	寒泰 Hantai	70.37	S	AR60	觉绿甘蓝 Juelü Cabbage	62.96	S
AR11	春蓝296 Chunlan 296	44.44	MR	AR61	越色 Yuese	48.15	MR
AR12	春蓝297 Chunlan 297	48.15	MR	AR62	似珍奇 Sizhenqi	33.33	MR
AR13	春蓝300 Chunlan 300	88.89	HS	AR63	XL60	70.37	S
AR14	20-2-5	62.96	S	AR64	XLMN	37.04	MR
AR15	23202	66.67	S	AR65	YC205	55.56	S
AR16	21-3	55.56	S	AR66	YC207	81.48	HS
AR17	台41 Tai 41	85.19	MR	AR67	YC207	66.67	S
AR18	24-5	74.07	S	AR68	96-100	51.85	MR
AR19	富士早生 Early Fuji	59.26	S	AR69	M3	74.07	S
AR20	非洲甜牛心 African Sweet Oxheart	66.67	S	AR70	嘉丽绿 Jiali Green	66.67	S
AR21	夏结254 Xiajie 254	77.78	HS	AR71	嘉丽灰 Jiali Gray	77.78	HS
AR22	似柳生288 Siliusheng 288	81.48	HS	AR72	越冬1 Yuedong 1	70.37	S
AR23	似柳生289 Siliusheng 289	51.85	MR	AR73	AQN	59.26	S
AR24	14秋494 14 Qiu 494	55.56	S	AR74	湖北48 Hubei 48	70.37	S
AR25	媛春 Yuanchun	48.15	MR	AR75	寒玉26 Hanyu 26	70.37	S
AR26	Gunma	74.07	S	AR76	甘蓝543 Cabbage 543	62.96	S
AR27	西六277 Xiliu 277	37.04	MR	AR77	瑞甘22 Ruigan 22	62.96	S
AR28	070	74.07	S	AR78	春味 Chunwei	40.74	MR
AR29	Going	59.26	S	AR79	寒4 Han 4	33.33	MR
AR30	泽雅 Zeya	55.56	S	AR80	JY81	33.33	MR
AR31	约旦扁球 Jordan Oblate	88.89	HS	AR81	春旺 Chunwang	53.70	MR
AR32	西四270 Xisi 270	70.37	S	AR82	07Cb18	33.33	MR
AR33	双流 Shuangliu	88.89	HS	AR83	春晓 Chunxiao	77.78	HS
AR34	QD37	77.78	HS	AR84	YFW1	59.26	S
AR35	19czb-1	66.67	S	AR85	好味来485 Haoweilai 485	40.74	MR
AR36	21LB3-1	66.67	S	AR86	亚马逊 Amazonas	48.15	MR
AR37	21CQ-1	85.19	HS	AR87	湖北1186-2 Hubei 1186-2	77.78	HS
AR38	1039	74.07	S	AR88	湖北1186-3 Hubei 1186-3	66.67	S
AR39	CB201-516	85.19	HS	AR89	绿宝石 Emerald	81.48	HS
AR40	CB201-520	92.59	HS	AR90	A1438	51.85	MR
AR41	CB201-521	85.19	HS	AR91	好味来525 Haoweilai 525	40.74	MR
AR42	希望720 Xiwang 720	59.26	S	AR92	米兰 Milan	62.96	S
AR43	希望721 Xiwang 721	70.37	S	AR93	A620	81.48	HS
AR44	吉宝 Jibao	48.15	MR	AR94	625甘蓝 625 Cabbage	77.78	HS
AR45	YFW2	77.78	HS	AR95	A901	51.85	MR
AR46	17HN82	66.67	S	AR96	A902	70.37	S
AR47	美一番 Meiyifan	62.96	S	AR97	C320	66.67	S
AR48	强绿625 Qianglü 625	66.67	S	AR98	牛心1 Oxheart 1	44.44	MR
AR49	天宝绿福 Tianbaolüfu	25.93	R	AR99	牛心10 Oxheart 10	55.56	S
AR50	T1000	37.04	MR	AR100	牛心33 Oxheart 33	66.67	S

[1]	LEI Na, ZHANG Liwei, DAI Zhongren, HU Haijiang, ZHANG Dong, MEN Wanjie. A New Chinese Cabbage Cultivar‘Habai 7’ [J]. Acta Horticulturae Sinica, 2026, 53(S1): 117-118.
[2]	CUI Jianchao, JIA Xiaohui, LI Litao, FAN Liying, ZHAO Wenshi, CHEN Long, WANG Xumin, HE Limin, XU Haijiao. Effect of Chitin Induction on Postharvest Sweet Cherry Fruit Against Black Spot and Storage Quality [J]. Acta Horticulturae Sinica, 2026, 53(5): 1425-1438.
[3]	BAI Xueying, TANG Manzhi, QU Tianhui, ZHANG Liting, XIAO Dong, LI Ying, HOU Xilin, LIU Tongkun. Identification of FRL Gene Family，Expression Analysis and Functional Study of BrcFRI1 in Non-Heading Chinese Cabbage [J]. Acta Horticulturae Sinica, 2026, 53(4): 1125-1142.
[4]	WANG Ronghua, LIU Shuantao, ZHAO Zhizhong, LI Qiaoyun, XU Nianfang, ZHANG Zhigang, WANG Shubin. Identification of the WSD Family Gene in Chinese Cabbage and Expression Analysis Under Drought Stress in Waxy Near-Isogenic Lines [J]. Acta Horticulturae Sinica, 2026, 53(4): 1143-1156.
[5]	CHEN Yanyan, YUE Chenxi, TU Hui, SHI Jikang, TAO Junjie, PAN Hui, LI Wenyi, LI Li, HUANG Chunhui. Evaluation of Resistance to Bacterial Canker Disease and Fungal Soft Rot and Fruit Quality of Jinfeng Kiwifruit Seed Offspring [J]. Acta Horticulturae Sinica, 2026, 53(3): 763-774.
[6]	ZHANG Changwei, LI Entong, WANG Wenlong, HOU Xilin. The Origin，Evolution，Research，and Industrial Development of Non- Heading Chinese Cabbage [J]. Acta Horticulturae Sinica, 2026, 53(3): 892-918.
[7]	ZHANG Yangyong, LÜ Honghao, WANG Yong, JI Jialei, $\boxed{\hbox{FANG Zhiyuan}}$, YANG Limei, ZHUANG Mu, YAO Xuehui, ZHOU Hongwei, YAN Xiangping. A New Cabbage Hybrid‘Zhonggan HD19’with High Taste Quality [J]. Acta Horticulturae Sinica, 2026, 53(3): 919-920.
[8]	WU Jue, SHI Yinghong, TANG Yuying, WANG Xinman, ZHAN Xiuping. Analysis and Evaluation of Agronomic Traits and Nutritional Quality in Different Types of Non-Heading Chinese Cabbage for Autumn-Winter Cultivation in Shanghai [J]. Acta Horticulturae Sinica, 2026, 53(1): 219-228.
[9]	XU Ligong, LI Na, YANG Xiaodong, SUN Jifeng, LÜ Xue, HAN Lujie, ZHOU Luhong. A New Summer Chinese Cabbage Hybrid‘Weibai 50’ [J]. Acta Horticulturae Sinica, 2025, 52(S2): 91-92.
[10]	LI Na, XU Ligong, SUN Jifeng, LÜ Xue, YANG Xiaodong, SUN Shasha, WANG Jin, ZHOU Feng. A New Miniature Chinese Cabbage Hybrid‘Weichun Jinbao’ [J]. Acta Horticulturae Sinica, 2025, 52(S2): 93-94.
[11]	LI Lin, YUAN Yuxiang, WEI Xiaochun, WANG Zhiyong, YANG Shuangjuan, ZHAO Yanyan, SU Henan, ZHANG Wenjing, WU Wenjing, ZHANG Xiaowei. A New Cultivar of Orange-Heart Chinese Cabbage‘Jimei 2’ [J]. Acta Horticulturae Sinica, 2025, 52(S2): 95-96.
[12]	LI Peirong, ZHAO Xiuyun, ZHANG Fenglan, YU Yangjun, ZHANG Deshuang, YU Shuancang, WANG Weihong, XIN Xiaoyun, ZHANG Bin, SU Tongbing. A New Heat-Resistant Non-Heading Chinese Cabbage Cultivar‘Guoxia 3’ [J]. Acta Horticulturae Sinica, 2025, 52(S2): 97-98.
[13]	ZHANG Wenqi, YANG Qinyu, YANG Xiao, ZHANG Li, HUANG Tao, OUYANG Lin, XU Hai, CHENG Longzheng, JING Zange, SONG Bo, YANG Qichang, LI Yuejian. A New Non-Heading Chinese Cabbage Cultivar‘Zhongshangqing 2’ [J]. Acta Horticulturae Sinica, 2025, 52(S2): 99-100.
[14]	LIU Zhaokun, WANG Huan, HAN Jianjun, WANG Yingying, ZHOU Hongzhang. A New Non-Heading Chinese Cabbage Cultivar‘Suqing 1’ [J]. Acta Horticulturae Sinica, 2025, 52(S2): 101-102.
[15]	ZHOU Jie, ZHANG Lei, WEI Lijun, WANG Qingming, WANG Yue’e, CAI Huaqing, LIU Daomin. A New Non-Heading Chinese Cabbage Cultivar‘Wan Cuilü’ [J]. Acta Horticulturae Sinica, 2025, 52(S2): 103-104.