观赏植物叶色嵌合体的研究进展

doi:10.16420/j.issn.0513-353x.2024-1060

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

叶色嵌合体独特的斑块或条纹状表型，在观赏植物育种中具有重要价值。因此，研究叶色嵌合体形成的分子调控机制对于定向改良观赏植物的叶色具有重要意义。本文中系统综述了叶色嵌合体的分类、分子调控机制及育种方法，重点从分子机制层面探讨了叶色嵌合体的形成原因以及人工定向培育叶色嵌合体的技术方法。并进一步指出目前该领域在质体发育、层间信号传导及其生存机制等核心问题上仍存在空白，未来需深入探索以指导其稳定创制与应用。

关键词: 观叶植物, 叶色嵌合体, 分子形成机制, 育种方法

Abstract:

The unique patchy or stripe-like phenotype of leaf variegation chimeras is of great value in ornamental plant breeding. Therefore，it is essential to study the molecular regulation mechanism of leaf variegation chimeras for the targeted improvement of ornamental plants with variegated leaves. This review summarizes the research progress on the classification，molecular regulatory mechanisms，and breeding methods of leaf variegation chimeras. It focuses on the molecular mechanisms underlying their formation and the technical approaches for artificially inducing leaf variegation chimeras. Furthermore，the review also summarizes the unresolved scientific issues in this field. It is further indicated that critical gaps exist in our understanding of several core areas，namely plastid development，interlayer signaling，and survival mechanisms. A more profound elucidation of these processes is imperative to inform strategies for their stable induction and practical application.

Key words: foliage plants, leaf variegation chimeras, molecular formation mechanism, breeding methods

齐晓庆, 高澄玥, 李浙浙, 杨秀莲, 王良桂, 岳远征. 观赏植物叶色嵌合体的研究进展[J]. 园艺学报, 2025, 52(12): 3401-3411.

QI Xiaoqing, GAO Chengyue, LI Zhezhe, YANG Xiulian, WANG Lianggui, YUE Yuanzheng. Research Progress on Leaf Variegation Chimeras of Ornamental Plants[J]. Acta Horticulturae Sinica, 2025, 52(12): 3401-3411.

图/表 5

参考文献 55

[1]	Aguilar-Méndez E D, Monribot-Villanueva J L, Guerrero-Analco J A, De-la-Peña C. 2024. Chlorophyll deficiency in Agave angustifolia Haw.:unveiling the impact on secondary metabolite production. Planta, 260(4):77.
[2]	Azarin K, Usatov A, Makarenko M, Kozel N, Kovalevich A, Dremuk I, Yemelyanova A, Logacheva M, Fedorenko A, Averina N. 2020. A point mutation in the photosystemⅠP700 chlorophyll a apoprotein A1 gene confers variegation in Helianthus annuus L. Plant Molecular Biology, 103:373-389.
[3]	Charuvi D, Kiss V, Nevo R, Shimoni E, Adam Z, Reich Z. 2012. Gain and loss of photosynthetic membranes during plastid differentiation in the shoot apex of Arabidopsis. The Plant Cell, 24(3):1143-1157.
[4]	Chen Lingyan, He Liting, Lai Jinli, He Shuting, Wu Yuxiang, Zheng Yushan. 2017. The variation of chlorophyll biosynthesis and the structure in different color leves of Bambusa multiplex‘Silverstripe’. Journal of Forest and Envionment,(37):385-391. (in Chinese)
	陈凌艳, 何丽婷, 赖金莉, 何舒婷, 吴玉香, 郑郁善. 2017. 银丝竹不同叶色叶绿素合成及叶结构差异. 森林与环境学报,(37):385-391.
[5]	Chen J C, Li Y Y, He D, Meng B, Li B, Zhang Q X, Luo L. 2022. Cytological,physiological and transcriptomic analysis of variegated leaves in Primulina Pungentisepala offspring. BMC Plant Biology, 22(1):419.
[6]	Chen X, He S, Wang Z, Zhai Y, Guo W, Li X. 2024. Production of transgenic periclinal chimeras in pumpkin-a tool for revealing cell fates of L1 meristem. Plant Biology, 26(1):126-139.
[7]	Datta S K. 2012. Success story of induced mutagenesis for development of new ornamental varieties. Bioremediation,Biodiversity and Bioavailability, 6(1):15-26.
[8]	Feng L J, Wang J T, Mao M Q, Yang W, Adje M O, Xue Y B, Zhou X X, Zhang H L, Luo J H, Tang R M, Tan L, Lin D P, Zhang X P, Zang Y Q, He Y H, Chen C M, Luan A P, Lin W Q, Xu W T, Li X, Sun L X, Jiang F X, Ma J. 2022. The highly continuous reference genome of a leaf-chimeric red pineapple(Ananas comosus var. bracteatus f. tricolor)provides insights into elaboration of leaf color. G3-Genes Genomes Genetics, 12(2):jkab452.
[9]	Filippis I, Lopez-cobollo R, Abbott J, Butcher S, Bishop G J. 2013. Using a periclinal chimera to unravel layer-specific gene expression in plants. The Plant Journal:for Cell and Molecular Biology, 75(6):1039-1049.
[10]	Frank M H, Chitwood D H. 2016. Plant chimeras:the good,the bad,and the‘Bizzaria’. Developmental Biology, 419(1):41-53.
[11]	Hirao T, Watanabe A, Kurita M, Kondo T, Takata K. 2009. A frameshift mutation of the chloroplast matK coding region is associated with chlorophyll deficiency in the Cryptomeria japonica virescent mutant“Wogon-Sugi”. Current Genetics, 55(3):311-321.
[12]	Hung C Y, Zhang J H, Bhattacharya C, Li H, Kittur F S, Oldham C E, Wei X Y, Burkey K O, Chen J J, Xie J H. 2021. Transformation of long-lived albino Epipremnum aureum‘Golden Pothos’and restoring chloroplast development. Frontiers in Plant Science, 12:647507.
[13]	Jiang T, Du K, Xie J, Sun G, Wang P, Chen X, Zhou T. 2023. Activated malate circulation contributes to the manifestation of light-dependent mosaic symptoms. Cell Reports, 42(4):112333.
[14]	Kayalvizhi K, Kannan M, Ganga M. 2017. Effect of physical and chemical mutagens on morphological characters in M₁V₂ generation of tuberose(Polianthes tuberosa L.). International Journal of Current Microbiology and Applied Sciences, 6:2492-2499.
[15]	Koh Y C, Davies F T. 2001. Mutagenesis and in vitro culture of Tillandsia fasciculata Swartz var. fasciculata(Bromeliaceae). Scientia Horticulturae, 87(3):225-240.
[16]	Kurniawan F Y, Putri S U, Linggabuwana A, Lawrie M D, Purwantoro A, Semiarti E. 2024. Mutation of the VAR2 gene plays a role as one of the causes of leaf variegation in the moth orchid Phalaenopsis‘Sogo Vivien’. Horticulture,Environment,and Biotechnology, 65:119-130.
[17]	Kusumi K, Chono Y, Shimada H, Gotoh E, Tsuyama M, Iba K. 2010. Chloroplast biogenesis during the early stage of leaf development in rice. Plant Biotechnology, 27(1):85-90.
[18]	Li Y R, Li W J, Hu D, Shen P, Zhang G H, Zhu Y. 2020. Comparative analysis of the metabolome and transcriptome between green and albino zones of variegated leaves from Hydrangea macrophylla Maculata infected by hydrangea ringspot virus. Plant Physiology and Biochemistry, 157:195-210.
[19]	Liu R Y, Dong X C, Zhang M M, Qu Y, Jin W J, Li X, Zhou L B, Yu L X, Li W J. 2021. Comparative transcriptome analysis reveals candidate genes for leaf color formation in a thermo-sensitive leaf-color mutant generated by carbon-ion beam in green wandering Jew(Tradescantia fluminensis). Scientia Horticulturae, 288:110300.
[20]	Lloyd A, Plaisier C L, Carroll D, Drews G N. 2005. Targeted mutagenesis using zinc-finger nucleases in Arabidopsis. Methods in Molecular Biology, 102(6):2232-2237.
[21]	Morimoto H, Narumi-kawasaki T, Takamura T, Fukai S. 2020. Flower color mutation caused by spontaneous cell layer displacement in carnation(Dianthus caryophyllus). Plant Science, 299:110598.
[22]	Ma J, Xiang H, Donnelly D J, Meng F R, Xu H M, Durnford D, Li X Q. 2017. Genome editing in potato plants by agrobacterium-mediated transient expression of transcription activator-like effector nucleases. Plant Biotechnology Reports, 11:249-258.
[23]	Mao L H, Zou Q C, Sun Z S, Dong Q, Cao X R. 2023. Insights into chloroplast genome structure,intraspecific variation,and phylogeny of Cyclamen species(Myrsinoideae). Scientific Reports, 13(1):87.
[24]	Mao Y F, Botella J R, Liu Y G, Zhu J K. 2019. Gene editing in plants:progress and challenges. National Science Review, 6(3):421-437.
[25]	Maynard R C I, Ruter J M. 2023. Mutation breeding of Salvia coccinea with ethyl methanesulfonate. Hort Science, 58(5):568-572.
[26]	Nishihara M, Higuchi A, Watanabe A, Tasaki K. 2018. Application of the CRISPR／Cas 9 system for modification of flower color in Torenia fournieri. BMC Plant Biology, 18(1):331.
[27]	Ossowski S, Schneeberger K, Lucas-Lledó J I, Warthmann N, Clark R M, Shaw R G, Weigel D, Lynch M. 2010. The rate and molecular spectrum of spontaneous mutations in Arabidopsis thaliana. Science, 327(5961):92-94.
[28]	Park H S, Jeon J H, Cho W, Lee Y, Park J Y, Kim J, Park Y S, Koo H J, Kang J H, Lee T J, Kim S H, Kim J B, Kwon H Y, Kim S H, Paek N C, Jang G, Suh J Y, Yang T J. 2022. High-throughput discovery of plastid genes causing albino phenotypes in ornamental chimeric plants. Horticulture Research, 49(5-6):689-705.
[29]	Pogson B J, Ganguly D, Albrecht-Borth V. 2015. Insights into chloroplast biogenesis and development. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta, 1847(9):1017-1024.
[30]	Qi X Y, Chen S S, Wang H D, Feng J, Chen H J, Qin Z Y, Deng Y M. 2022. Comparative physiology and transcriptome analysis reveals that chloroplast development influences silver-white leaf color formation in Hydrangea macrophylla var. maculata. BMC Plant Biology, 22(1):345.
[31]	Reddy G V. 2008. Live-imaging stem-cell homeostasis in the Arabidopsis shoot apex. Current Opinion in Plant Biology, 11(1):88-93.
[32]	Richter A S, Nägele T, Grimm B, Kaufmann K, Schroda M, Leister D, Kleine T. 2023. Retrograde signaling in plants:a critical review focusing on the GUN pathway and beyond. Plant Communications, 4(1):100511.
[33]	Ran Haoran, Zhang Yu, Chen Jancun, Yu Chao, Zhang Qixiang, Luo Le. 2024. Advances in the study of leaf spots in ornamental plants. Journal of Plant Genetic Resources, 25(5):704-717. (in Chinese)
	冉浩然, 张毓, 陈简村, 于超, 张启翔, 罗乐. 2024. 观赏植物叶斑的研究进展. 植物遗传资源学报, 25(5):704-717.
[34]	Sakamoto W. 2003. Leaf-variegated mutations and their responsible genes in Arabidopsis thaliana. Genes & Genetic Systems, 78(1):1-9.
[35]	Sakamoto W, Uno Y, Zhang Q, Miura E, Kato Y, Sodmergen. 2009. Arrested differentiation of proplastids into chloroplasts in variegated leaves characterized by plastid ultrastructure and nucleoid morphology. Plant and Cell Physiology, 50(12):2069-2083.
[36]	Sauer N J, Mozoruk J, Miller R B, Warburg Z J, Walker K A, Beetham P R, Schöpke C R, Gocal G F W. 2016. Oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis for precision gene editing. Plant Biotechnology Journal, 14(2):496-502.
[37]	Shih T H, Lin S H, Huang M Y, Huang W D, Yang C M. 2019. Transcriptome profile of the variegated Ficus microcarpa c.v. milky stripe fig leaf. International Journal of Molecular Sciences, 20(6):1338.
[38]	Sikora P, Chawade A, Larsson M, Olsson J, Olsson O. 2011. Mutagenesis as a tool in plant genetics,functional genomics,and breeding. International Journal of Plant Genomics, 2011(1):314829.
[39]	Singh V P, Singh M, Pal J P. 1999. Mutagenic effects of gamma rays and EMS on frequency and spectrum of chlorophyll and macromutations in urdbean(Vigna mungo L. Hepper). Indian Journal of Genetics and Plant Breeding, 59(2):203-210.
[40]	Smith A G, Noyszewski A K. 2018. Mutagenesis breeding for seedless varieties of popular landscape plants. Acta Horticulturae, 1191:43-52.
[41]	Talebi A B, Talebi A B, Shahrokhifar B. 2012. Ethyl methane sulphonate(EMS)induced mutagenesis in malaysian rice(cv. MR219)for lethal dose determination. American Journal of Plant Sciences, 3:1661-1665.
[42]	Tsai C C, Wu Y J, Sheue C R, Liao P C, Chen Y H, Li S J, Liu J W, Chang H T, Liu W L, Ko Y Z, Chiang Y C. 2017. Molecular basis underlying leaf variegation of a moth orchid mutant(Phalaenopsis aphrodite subsp. formosana). Frontiers in Plant Science, 8:1333.
[43]	Wang N, Zhu T, Lu N, Wang Z, Yang G, Qu G, Kong L, Zhang S, Ma W, Wang J. 2019. Quantitative phosphoproteomic and physiological analyses provide insights into the formation of the variegated leaf in Catalpa fargesii. International Journal of Molecular Sciences, 20(8):1895.
[44]	Wu W, Elsheery N, Wei Q, Zhang L, Huang J. 2011. Defective etioplasts observed in variegation mutants may reveal the light-independent regulation of white/yellow sectors of Arabidopsis leaves. Journal of Integrative Plant Biology, 53(11):846-857.
[45]	Wu Y, Zheng Y, Xu W, Zhang Z, Li L, Wang Y, Cui J, Wang Q M. 2023. Chimeric deletion mutation of rpoC2 underlies the leaf-patterning of Clivia miniata var. variegata. Plant Cell Reports, 42(9):1419-1431.
[46]	Xue Y, Ma J, He Y, Yu S, Lin Z, Xiong Y, Rafique F, Jiang F, Sun L, Ma M, Zhou Y, Li X, Huang Z. 2019. Comparative transcriptomic and proteomic analyses of the green and white parts of chimeric leaves in Ananas comosus var. bracteatus. PeerJ, 7:e7261.
[47]	Yan Junfang, Tan Miaomiao, Chen Chi, Wang Lei, Tan Jianzhong. 2014. Ornamental plant flower color chimeras and their application in breeding. Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences, 42(6):1600-1602. (in Chinese)
	闫俊芳, 谭苗苗, 陈驰, 王蕾, 谈建中. 2014. 观赏植物花色嵌合体及其育种学应用. 安徽农业科学, 42(6):1600-1602.
[48]	Yan R, Wang Z P, Ren Y M, Li H Y, Liu N, Sun H M. 2019. Establishment of efficient genetic transformation systems and application of CRISPR/Cas 9 genome editing technology in Lilium pumilum DC. Fisch. and Lilium longiflorum white heaven. International Journal of Molecular Sciences, 20(12):2920.
[49]	Yu F, Fu A, Aluru M, Park S, Xu Y, Liu H, Liu X, Foudree A, Nambogga M, Rodermel S. 2007. Variegation mutants and mechanisms of chloroplast biogenesis. Plant,Cell & Environment, 30(3):350-365.
[50]	Yu X F, Yue L J, He Q L, Li S R, Zheng Y L, Wang Z W, Wang H T, Liu R Z, Huang X, Xiao X, Yang L J, Lei T. 2023. Transcriptome analysis of Iris japonica var. variegata for chlorophyll and photosynthesis-related pathways involved in white-green striped leaves. Acta Physiologiae Plantarum, 46:12.
[51]	Zhang J H, Zeng J C, Wang X M, Chen S F, Albach D C, Li H Q. 2020. A revised classification of leaf variegation types. Flora, 272:151703.
[52]	Zhang Q, Huang J, Zhou P, Hao M Z, Zhang M. 2021. Cytological and transcriptomic analysis provide insights into the formation of variegated leaves in Ilex × altaclerensis‘Belgica Aurea’. Plants, 10(3):552.
[53]	Zhang Y, Wang J, Ma W, Lu N, Fu P, Yang Y, Zhao L, Hu J, Qu G, Wang N. 2023. Transcriptome-wide m6A methylation in natural yellow leaf of Catalpa fargesii. Frontiers in Plant Science, 14:1167789.
[54]	Zhao H, Diao S F, Liu P F, Luo Y, Wuyun T N, Zhu G P. 2018. The communication of endogenous biomolecules(RNA,DNA,protein,hormone)via graft union might play key roles in the new traits formation of graft hybrids. Pakistan Journal of Botany, 50(2):717-726.
[55]	Zhou S, Ma K, Mower J P, Liu Y, Zhou R. 2024. Leaf variegation caused by plastome structural variation:an example from Dianella tasmanica. Horticulture Research, 11(3):uhae009.

序号No.	名称 Name	分子机制 Molecular mechanism	参考文献 Reference
1	蝴蝶兰 Phalaenopsis aphrodite	VAR2单核苷酸插入 VAR2 single nucleotide insertion	Kurniawan et al.,2024
2	斑叶君子兰 Clivia miniata	rpoC2的长片段缺失突变 Long fragment deletion mutation in rpoC2	Wu et al.,2023
3	向日葵 Helianthus annuus	psaA点突变 Point mutation in psaA	Azarin et al.,2020
4	黄金葛 Epipremnum aureum	EaZIP转录水平差异或早期EaZIP转录物无法有效积累 EaZIP transcript level differences or ineffective accumulation of early EaZIP transcripts	Hung et al.,2021
5	尖萼报春苣苔 Primulina pungentisepala	CHL-2上调 CHL-2 upregulation	Chen et al.,2022
6	小果榕 Ficus microcarpa	psba、psbb、psbc和psbd均下调；clh1 和clh2 上调；mTERF缺陷 psba，psbb，psbc and psbd are all downregulated；clh1 and clh2 are upregulated；mTERF deficiency	Shih et al.,2019
7	日本鸢尾 Iris japonica	GLK下调 GLK downregulation	Yu et al.,2023
8	绣球花 Hydrangea macrophylla	HmAP2/ERFs下调 HmAP2/ERFs downregulation	Qi et al.,2022
9	虎杖 Reynoutria japonica	rpoC2点突变 rpoC2 point mutation	Park et al.,2022
10	垂叶榕 Ficus benjamina	rpoC1短片段缺失 Short fragment deletion in rpoC1	Park et al.,2022
11	粉花绣线菊 Spiraea japonica	rpoB短片段插入 Short fragment insertion in rpoB	Park et al.,2022
12	南美榕 Ficus natalensis	rpoB短片段插入 Short fragment insertion in rpoB	Park et al.,2022
13	木槿 Hibiscus syriacus	rpoB短片段插入Short fragment insertion in rpoB	Park et al.,2022
14	洋常春藤 Hedera helix	psaA短片段缺失 Short fragment deletion in psaA	Park et al.,2022
15	合果芋 Syngonium podophyllum	rpoB短片段缺失Short fragment deletion in rpoB	Park et al.,2022
16	日本柳杉 Cryptomeria japonica	matK短片段插入突变 Short fragment insertion mutation in matK	Hirao et al., 2009
17	大花惠兰 Cymbidium hybrid	ycf3点突变 ycf3 point mutation	Park et al.,2022
18	墨兰 Cymbidium sinense	atpI短片段插入 Short fragment insertion in atpI	Park et al.,2022
19	长柄玉簪 Hosta longipes	atpE短片段插入 Short fragment insertion in atpE	Park et al.,2022
20	吊兰 Chlorophytum comosum	rpoC2短片段缺失 Short fragment deletion in rpoC2	Park et al.,2022
21	富贵竹 Dracaena sanderiana	ycf3内含子点突变 Intronic point mutation in ycf3	Park et al.,2022
22	红苞凤梨 Ananas comosus	VDE、PSY、PDS上调；GS和GDH下调； GLK1、PLA2、FTIP4、AS特异性表达 VDE，PSY，PDS upregulated；GS and GDH downregulated；GLK1，PLA2，FTIP4，AS specifically expressed	Xue et al.,2019； Feng et al.,2022
23	长果山菅 Dinaella tasmanica	psbA、matK、rps16和trnK的消除 Elimination of psbA，matK，rps16 and trnK	Zhou et al.,2024
24	台湾蝴蝶兰 Phalaenopsis aphrodite	PsbO和PsbP下调 PsbO and PsbP downregulated	Tsai et al.,2017
25	常春藤叶仙客来 Cyclamen hederifolium	基因间区域rps4-trnT-UGU的插入/缺失突变 Insertion/Deletion mutation in the intergenic region rps4-trnT-UGU	Mao et al.,2023
26	楸树 Catalpa fargesii	PPOX、LHCB1、PsbO、PsbP、PsbQ和PsbR磷酸化差异；CfALKBH5调控m6A甲基化来调控基因表达 Phosphorylation differences in PPOX，LHCB1，PsbO，PsbP，PsbQ，and PsbR；CfALKBH5 regulates gene expression by modulating m6A methylation	Wang et al.,2019；Zhang et al.,2023

序号No.	名称 Name	分子机制 Molecular mechanism	参考文献 Reference
1	蝴蝶兰 Phalaenopsis aphrodite	VAR2单核苷酸插入 VAR2 single nucleotide insertion	Kurniawan et al.,2024
2	斑叶君子兰 Clivia miniata	rpoC2的长片段缺失突变 Long fragment deletion mutation in rpoC2	Wu et al.,2023
3	向日葵 Helianthus annuus	psaA点突变 Point mutation in psaA	Azarin et al.,2020
4	黄金葛 Epipremnum aureum	EaZIP转录水平差异或早期EaZIP转录物无法有效积累 EaZIP transcript level differences or ineffective accumulation of early EaZIP transcripts	Hung et al.,2021
5	尖萼报春苣苔 Primulina pungentisepala	CHL-2上调 CHL-2 upregulation	Chen et al.,2022
6	小果榕 Ficus microcarpa	psba、psbb、psbc和psbd均下调；clh1 和clh2 上调；mTERF缺陷 psba，psbb，psbc and psbd are all downregulated；clh1 and clh2 are upregulated；mTERF deficiency	Shih et al.,2019
7	日本鸢尾 Iris japonica	GLK下调 GLK downregulation	Yu et al.,2023
8	绣球花 Hydrangea macrophylla	HmAP2/ERFs下调 HmAP2/ERFs downregulation	Qi et al.,2022
9	虎杖 Reynoutria japonica	rpoC2点突变 rpoC2 point mutation	Park et al.,2022
10	垂叶榕 Ficus benjamina	rpoC1短片段缺失 Short fragment deletion in rpoC1	Park et al.,2022
11	粉花绣线菊 Spiraea japonica	rpoB短片段插入 Short fragment insertion in rpoB	Park et al.,2022
12	南美榕 Ficus natalensis	rpoB短片段插入 Short fragment insertion in rpoB	Park et al.,2022
13	木槿 Hibiscus syriacus	rpoB短片段插入Short fragment insertion in rpoB	Park et al.,2022
14	洋常春藤 Hedera helix	psaA短片段缺失 Short fragment deletion in psaA	Park et al.,2022
15	合果芋 Syngonium podophyllum	rpoB短片段缺失Short fragment deletion in rpoB	Park et al.,2022
16	日本柳杉 Cryptomeria japonica	matK短片段插入突变 Short fragment insertion mutation in matK	Hirao et al., 2009
17	大花惠兰 Cymbidium hybrid	ycf3点突变 ycf3 point mutation	Park et al.,2022
18	墨兰 Cymbidium sinense	atpI短片段插入 Short fragment insertion in atpI	Park et al.,2022
19	长柄玉簪 Hosta longipes	atpE短片段插入 Short fragment insertion in atpE	Park et al.,2022
20	吊兰 Chlorophytum comosum	rpoC2短片段缺失 Short fragment deletion in rpoC2	Park et al.,2022
21	富贵竹 Dracaena sanderiana	ycf3内含子点突变 Intronic point mutation in ycf3	Park et al.,2022
22	红苞凤梨 Ananas comosus	VDE、PSY、PDS上调；GS和GDH下调； GLK1、PLA2、FTIP4、AS特异性表达 VDE，PSY，PDS upregulated；GS and GDH downregulated；GLK1，PLA2，FTIP4，AS specifically expressed	Xue et al.,2019； Feng et al.,2022
23	长果山菅 Dinaella tasmanica	psbA、matK、rps16和trnK的消除 Elimination of psbA，matK，rps16 and trnK	Zhou et al.,2024
24	台湾蝴蝶兰 Phalaenopsis aphrodite	PsbO和PsbP下调 PsbO and PsbP downregulated	Tsai et al.,2017
25	常春藤叶仙客来 Cyclamen hederifolium	基因间区域rps4-trnT-UGU的插入/缺失突变 Insertion/Deletion mutation in the intergenic region rps4-trnT-UGU	Mao et al.,2023
26	楸树 Catalpa fargesii	PPOX、LHCB1、PsbO、PsbP、PsbQ和PsbR磷酸化差异；CfALKBH5调控m6A甲基化来调控基因表达 Phosphorylation differences in PPOX，LHCB1，PsbO，PsbP，PsbQ，and PsbR；CfALKBH5 regulates gene expression by modulating m6A methylation	Wang et al.,2019；Zhang et al.,2023